Proofreading and Copy Editing

They're not the same

These terms are often used interchangeably but they are not the same. They are separate activities, although there is some overlap between the two.


Proofreading

Proofreading consists of reviewing a document for typographical, spelling, punctuation, and formatting errors. This may be done either against an original document or "blind". Many proofreaders are also required to take on some light copy editing duties, such as checking for grammar and consistency problems. Proofreading is usually the final check of the work before publication.

Copy Editing

The copy editor's job is summarized in the Five Cs: to make the copy clear, correct, concise, comprehensible, and consistent. It encompasses proofreading and requires a formidable command of the language, a great eye for detail, broad general knowledge, and sharp critical thinking skills. A major part of the copy editor's job is to preserve the author's voice or style while making any necessary changes to the text.

The copy editor is expected to ensure that the text flows, that it is sensible, fair, and accurate, and that it will provoke no legal problems for the publisher. Newspaper copy editors are sometimes responsible for choosing which news service wire copy the newspaper will use, and for rewriting it in accordance with house style. Often, the copy editor is the only person other than the author to read an entire text before its publication. Newspaper editors often regard copy editors as the newspaper's last line of accurate defense.

A copy editor may abridge text, by "cutting" and "trimming" it, to reduce the length of a novel or an article, either to fit broadcast or publishing limits or to improve its meaning. This may involve omitting parts of the text, but sometimes it is necessary to rewrite uncut parts to bridge the missing details and plot; some abridgements are only slightly shorter than the originals, but others may be much abridged, particularly when a literary classic is abridged for the children's market.[1]

Interestingly, there is no agreement on the form of the term; it is spelled as one word (copyediting), two words (copy editing), or hyphenated (copy-editing). All are correct, the hyphenated version being more prevalent in the United Kingdom.

Online Resources


Best of All Words: Proofreading and copy editing service.

The Free Dictionary: This is a great site and includes a dictionary, thesaurus, medical dictionary, legal dictionary,
language dictionaries, games, and more.

Acronyms and Abbreviations: Also from The Free Dictionary, an exhaustive compilation of acronyms and abbreviations.

Dictionary.com: Another great online dictionary with tools, thesaurus, grammar, usage and style, and more.

Crosswords Puzzles: From the Washington Post.

Free Rice: Build your vocabulary while helping the UN World Food Program end hunger.

Weird Words: From World Wide Words.

Pseudodictionary: Words that should be in the dictionary but aren't. Readers can submit their own pseudowords.

References

  1. Answers.com

Comments

Bestlinks

The links you given are familiar and useful for Copyeditors. Update as this profession goes up.

Last edited Sep 21, 2008 7:55 AM
Report abusive comment

Thanks Nick

Yes, reading aloud is a simple and effective way to proofread! Thanks for your comment.

Aug 10, 2008 4:19 PM
Report abusive comment

Nice Article

I like your definitions and the resources. I do a lot of proofreading and copy editing. My personal favorite trick - whether you're just looking for grammatical inaccuracies or you're trying to clean up the content - is to read out loud. Not a mind blowing trick by any means, but it really does work.

Last edited Aug 8, 2008 8:24 AM
Report abusive comment
Article rating:
Your rating:

Categories

Based on community consensus.

Activity for this knol

This week:

6pageviews

Totals:

450pageviews
3comments