Knol will be unavailable during scheduled maintenance starting at Mon, 09 Nov 2009 18:30:00 GMT. We expect the maintenance to be completed at Mon, 09 Nov 2009 20:00:00 GMT.
Version: Baidi441

Review of Muscle Cramping


Reading this article reminds me of being in class at Martin Schwellnus' University and being directed to study material in a textbook or peer reviewed publication.
I feel a knol gives more satisfaction when commonplace experience/knowledge/investigation in the backyard is shared. Textbook like material is already abundant and widely available.
To illustrate my sentiment, please review my knol Pain.
Much of what Schwellnus relates equates to the somewhat vague but elaborate catalogue of conditions and would be far more useful if based (maybe) on personal experience or insight gained from his expertise.
To illustrate, cramping is most commonly experienced in sports!  Classical sports diets (as in diets advocated by high school footbal coaches in the 1950s and 60s) were high protein diets. Protein digestion requires far more water by the body than carbohydrate or fat and to rely on protein as the larger source of energy requires water, often beyond the body's need for intense muscle function. And excessive salt consumption was then advocated to help retain more water.....throwing the entire physiology out of balance.
Information like this can be gleaned from textbook like publication like this but is not as readily available to the general readership lacking academic training or exposure.
Hide questionnaire
Do you trust this person as an expert on this knol's topic?
No
YesNo opinion
Do you believe this content is original and/or correctly attributed?
No
YesNo opinion
Did you find this knol useful?
No
YesNo opinion
Is this knol a complete and thorough treatment of its topic?
No
YesNo opinion
Is this knol a pleasure to read, making good use of layout, style and media?
No
YesNo opinion
Does this document cite adequate and reliable references to support its claims?
No
YesNo opinion
Is this knol as good or better than the top 10 search results on its topic?
No
YesNo opinion
Does this knol promote a product or service?
No
YesNo opinion

Comments

Bert van Wijck
Bert van Wijck
Rancher
The Everglades in Florida
Reviewed knol:

Rating awarded:
Version: 2
Versions
Last edited: Aug 23, 2008 10:29 AM.

Bert van Wijck also wrote

Activity for this knol

This week:

15pageviews

Totals:

144pageviews