Where Are We?
On 20th June 2009
Presently knol authors could be 10,000 in number.
Knols could be 200,000.
Quantcast says knol is a top 10,000 site.
The last official announcement was that 100,000 knols were published. In the six month period that followed another 100,000 could have been produced (Statement in the first version of the knol).
Further updates
I saw in the comment by knol help to a knol http://knol.google.com/k/seeger-carbajal/knol-users-group-knols-2009/3p29xkwpauy98/3# that by 2 March 2009, there were 125,000 knols. Now I feel more confident that my estimate that there will be 200,000 knols (by 22 July 2009) will be correct.
Peter Baskerville in a comment in the knol help bulletin board http://knol.google.com/k/knol-help/general-feedback-about-the-knol-site/si57lahl1w25/204# stated that knol has amassed 230,000 knols (15th July 2009). Therefore the estimate of 200,000 knols was already achieved. This information gives us more confidence about our further future estimates.
What Should Be Our Goal?
Knol authors: 100,000
Knols: 1,000,000
Knol: A top 100 web site
Knol pageviews: Average 1 million per day.
Visitors: Maximum 1 million per day
Target Time For The Goal
Second year of full scale operation.
Knol will complete first year of full operation in July 2009. The target of 1 million knols is for July 2010.
Is It Feasible?
Yes, If Squidoo has done it in 3 years and odd, Google can do in 2 years. See HubPages, Knol, Squidoo, Wikipedia and Other Article Sites - Comparison.
Knol Metrics authors say more emphatically that there are 240,000 knols. Around 140,000 knols were written six months. Assuming 180 days in these six month, 800 knols per day were written by knol authors. If authors who joined at different time points could write 240,000 knols in one year, how many knols they can write in full year? My estimate is that they will write 375,000 knols. One is already witnessing a trend, that some of the authors who wrote in earlier days are becoming active now. This large number of authors are going to join compared to last year. If last year around 25,000 authors have joined, this year my estimate is that 75,000 more authors are going join. Very difficult, no. If subscribers to twitter can go up from one million to 23 million in one year, how can one say 75,000 authors will not register in a year. Now authors are able to see statistics for their articles in existence. Some of them are getting very good page views. I came across an author who is getting more than 50,000 page views a week. Some more authors may show similar performance. In the month of September 2009, page views increased for many authors. For my knol portfolio, the peak page for week are 24,200. This is a very satisfying number and adsense revenues are going up along with this page view increase. Authors need not complain about the platform anymore. The performance of their knol portfolio depends upon the number of articles they have written, the amount and quality of content that they have posted and the promotion that they have done for their article (Digg.com for Article Marketing, Reading and Appreciating).
Some of the authors are making some money however small it is. Somebody $15 every month, some body $15 once in three months and may be somebody in $15 in six months. But it started. Remember, 100,000 page views may give $100. Hence an author with 50,000 page views per week can make $200 a month. Many knols are appearing in google search results. There is excitement and authors are going join. Actually, I am underestimating when I say that 75,000 new authors write 375,000 knols. There can be a positive surprise and the new authors may write many more.
What Needs To Be Done?
There was tremendous adverse publicity against knol. Even now it is continuing but in a muted way. Many potential authors must have dropped plans to write on the platform due to the adverse publicity. But the team which is managing knol has shown restraint and went about the job of building knol in a very polite and calm manner. They achieved the minimum required author base and knol base. A public applause for their start-up effort should motivate them to take an aggressive stance and declare aggressive targets and create confidence in many that knol platform is here to stay with strategy to be the Number one wiki based article website.
There are many niches in the knowledge area that knol can play a pioneering role and there are many segments of people who have the knowledge to share that knol can attract to the platform.
Kaizen Budgeting
There are estimates that say Knol will have 250,000 articles by the time it ends its first year. This makes achievement one million knols more feasible. But a kaizen budget that gives weekly target for knols is to be prepared and each week knol needs to run a promotion in one of the countries for increasing authors, knols and visitors. It can tie up with at least one higher educational institute in each country for encouraging their faculty to write knols and for encouraging their students to use knol. Such weekly promotions will bring in more and more authors and visitors to the knol platform and provide continuous encouragement to existing authors.
Knol - SWOT Analysis
Strengths
- Started by Google Which is a savvy player in Website business domain.
- Technical competence of Google in software as well as in efficienty using hardware to deliver exceptional service to website visitors.
- Knol has positioned itself a knowledge site committed to promote online learning (It has not given undue importance to advertising).
Weaknesses
- Late entry into the market with a well established market leader.
- No special technology innovation in the platform.
- Low key entry.
- Lack of a visible "knowledge expert team" that is guiding the roll out.
- Revenue model for authors (First year nobody made any significant revenue).
Opportunities
- Many institutes have not provided publishing opportunity to their faculty.
- Ph.d theses can be published on knol.
- School/College/Institute/Alumni Magazines can have knol versions.
- Management Development Course Modules can be hosted on knol.
Threats
- While negative publicity has subsided it may resurface as competitors feel if they cannot attack now, there is no chance in the future.
How Many Knols Were Written So Far?
Knol help has given the following suggestion to estimate the knols written so far.
How many knols have been published?
We don't provide an official number, but there are two easy ways you can estimate the number.
- Look at the number of search results that google.com returns for the search [site:knol.google.com]
- Look at the number of search results that the Search Toolkit returns for a common word in a language of interest. For example, search for [a].
Using either technique, you can estimate the number of published knols in a particular language by restricting the search to a particular language.
15.10.2009
I searched using google search and the dates 6/1/2008 to 10/13/2009 and the search returned 606,000 entries.
For English language only, it returned 314,000 entries. For Arabic language it returned 85,000 entries. For French it returned 38,400 entries.For Spanish, it returned 39,100.For German, it returned 23,300. For Korean, it returned only 871 entries.For Chinese simplified 536 entries were shown. For Chinese Traditional, 99 knols were shown. For Italian, it showed 25,600 entries. For Russian, it showed only 480 knols. Japanese knols were only 484. For Greek, it showed only 244 knols. For Dutch, it showed only 309 knols. No Indian language were shown in the Google search options.
At this moment, it is difficult for me to interpret these figures.
5.11.2009
Today the search for number of knols returned 345,000 knols for the last one year. Yesterday, under any time option it had shown 405,000. We can take it that there are around 400,000 knols on the platform today. Will they become 1,000,000 by end July 2010.
Knol Author Team - Role and Responsibility
Knol author team is not a monolithic group. It is more like athletes in an olympic village. All embody the olympic spirit. But they represent different events and countries. So there are subgroups across events and countries.
Knol author subgroups are much more diverse. Country, Language, Subject, Level of audience addressed, Authors' educational qualifications, Knol writing objectives and Commitment to the writing activity are some of the dimensions on which subgroups can be identified.
The author team has to actively collaborate while competing to increase the knol author base, knol article base and knol visitor base.
Dr. Meredith Belbin identified nine team roles in teams big or small. These roles have a specific contribution to make for the team's success and some individuals have an inclination to play some roles dominantly.
Nine team roles are identified by Belbin
- Completer - Finisher
- Coordinator
- Implementor
- Monitor - Evaluator
- Plant
- Resource Investigator
- Shaper
- Specialist
- Teamworker
The opportunities can be identified by one. But others have to step in complete the task. No big project can be completed with a simple desire. Resources have to identified. We require people who are willing to look around and identify the resources. We need some people who act as coordinators and keep the team aligned. Knol requires both quantity and quality. There is no conflict between them. Authors have to help each other in identifying new ideas for writing knols and in identifying opportunities for improving the quality of a knol on a theme. We require many teamworkers, who behave in way that people feel pleasure to approach them.
We require specialists in various areas - subject matter, knol aesthetics, language, html and other technical issues, knol marketing as well as human relations so that the team performs and prospers. We need monitors and of course completer-finishers who actually take the ball past the goal post.
Knol author team requires active knol authors with strong commitment to the platform who contribute individually and then contribute to the team.
Recruiting New Authors
Knol authors can take a target of recruiting one author in each quarter of the coming years. Knol Author Recruitment - Double the Number of Knol Authors is an attempt in this regard. I find more persons are receptive to the idea of writing knols now. Some attempt by authors to bring up the issue and encouraging them to begin writing on knol will convert many into knol authors.
Each existing author can take a target or recruting 4 authors, one in each quarter during the next year. Then the new authors can also be encouraged to recruit new authors in turn. Recruitment of knol authors has to be a movement till a solid network of author sufficient to sustain the platform with adequate cash flow and profitabilty is established.
Writing More Knols
Promoting and Marketing Knols
Ways to promote Knol Site and Knol Articles is the theme of importance. Every author has to do his bit to promote the knol site, his knols as well as others knols. Many authors are promoting their knols through their blogs. Some of the blogs seem to blogs on a particular area like dental care etc. and knols are being mentioned in them. Such promotion will yield results. Authors can recommend knols of other authors also to their network of friends. Knol Directory - List of Interesting Knol Lists is an attempt to provide a list of interesting knols to knol authors so that they can identify and recommend some of the knols in their circle of influence.
Using article sharing sites like Digg.com(Digg.com for Article Marketing, Reading and Appreciating) and friend feed etc. is required. Use twitter to inform others when you complete a knol posting. Inform your friends through mail when you post a knol relevant to them. Join knowledge sharing networks like linkedin, orkut, facebook and other discussion boards and inform your online articles.
________________________________________________________________________________________
Knol Directory of Interesting Knols - Main Categories
Authors can include their knols that have more than 500 page views in intersting article directory pages and knols having less than 500 page views in new knol directory pages.
______________________________________________________________________________________
Relevant and Comprehensive Knols
Knols have to be relevant to the needs of visitors. Then they have to comprehensive. Authors have to understand various features provided by the knol platform to provide a good experience to visitors and then come out with comprehensive content to provide a service to the visitor. Authors should not think of their benefit or reward first. First think of service to the visitor. What does the visitor want? What can you provide? Is it satisfactory to the visitor? Find out and whenever a visitor expresses his opinion for improvement in the knol, respond instantaneously.
Knol authors need to make constructive suggestions to other authors. Whenever you come across a knol that needs improvement according to you, say it gently as a comment. Be ready to appreciate also. Start with a statement that the topic of the knol is relevant. Then state your suggestions for improvement.
Knol Quality Ratings
Knol was unnecessarily subjected to a criticism on quality issue. If people are free to write articles they will publish poor quality articles. This is a generic argument. Its relevance is less as there are many websites where there is people generated content and they are in the top 10, top 25 and top 50 and top 100 categories. Are there no poor quality articles in them? Certainly there will be poor quality articles. But they do not reach the visitors. They never show up in search engine results. I am doing searches on knol during the last few days to develop subject-wise sub-directories of interesting knols. Knol Directory - List of Interesting Knol Lists. There are many articles with more than 500 page views in the last one year, which is a good number and there are many with 10 or 15 page views. Nobody will look at those articles with 10 or 15 page views when they can look at 500 page view article or a 5000 page view article. A poor article may exist on a site,but it will not affect the visitor community a lot. They will not stumble upon it unless they are curious to know what is so bad in it that it had only 15 page views till that time.
But to satisfy the critics and also to satisfy itself, knol has set up a top quality rating badge above the five star ratings that it created for visitors to rank articles. It is a good sign that there are 1565 top quality articles on knol at this point in time and this number is going up every day. Knol management can publish the number of 5 star quality articles, 4 star quality articles and 3 star quality articles. Such publication of statistics will encourage visitors to give ratings more frequently and keep the ratings in proper order. There is no big worry of manipulation of ratings, because if 50 people visit and all give five star ratings what is the author going to get out of it. He may feel happy that he asked his friends to give positive ratings. It may not really affect visitors if visitors are not interested in that topic at all. Unless visitors are interested in a topic, they will not search for it. There is already enormous information in the web about each and every topic. Every author has to create some thing different and valuable and then only marketing and promotion work. When people have not produced a proper product, they cannot sell the product despite great efforts.
Knol platform management and knol authors have to focus on developing more and more high quality articles and have to put in place a mechanism to discard extremely poor or noncompliant articles. At the middle range they should allow authors to use their judgment in response to the reactions from genuine visitors to their knols.
Knol Page Views
The top 800 knols had a total of 8,350,540 page views as on 29.7.2009 (estimated). Page Views for Top 800 Knols.This figure gives an average daily viewership of 28.6 per day.
Can Knol achieve 365 million page views in the second year? An answer is attempted below.
Knol Page View and Knol Quality Relation (Expected)
On a base of 1,000,000 ( one million) knols the following relation can be expected
First 100,000 knols - 300,000 page views per day (3 page views per knol per day)
Next 100,000 knols - 150,000 page views per day (1.5 pv pk per day)
Next 300,000 knols - 300,000 page views per day (1 pv pk per day)
Next 500,000 knols - 250,000 page views per day (0.5 pv pk per day)
This scheme estimates that knols will have at an average one page view per day. Is it feasible? I am the author of maximum number knols as on date. Many people criticize me for my quantity. According to knol page view counter I am having around 3000 page views per day (24,000 pv per week). According to google analytics my knol page view number has peaked at 1233. I think the difference in page views between analytics and knol page view counter could be because analytics does not capture page views in other language domains like (kr) etc. So if my knols can have average page views of one per day, I can expect a similar number for many authors who are writing smaller number of knols with better care, attention and detail.
Can there be 25,000 knols with knol quality badges? Yes, there are many authors who are writing smaller number of knols and concentrating a lot in competing with existing articles on net to get into top 10 slot. I think more and more knols with quality badges will be posted. I expressed the hope that 25,000 quality badge knols will be there in a comment on knol help bulletin board.
Open Collaboration Knols
Provide an opportunity to visitors to collaborate
Open collaboration feature is a unique feature of knol platform in comparison to blogger platform for publishing articles. Authors have to leverage this feature to converge the knowledge of large number of persons in the world into a knol. It is suggested that every author have at least one open collaboration knol at any point in time. When 100,000 knol authors are there, there will be 100,000 open collaboration knols. They provide opportunity to visitors to collaborate and visitors may come back twice or thrice to add material to the knol and also they will tell their friends to visit the knol as they have added the material. Open Collaboration Knols - Leveraging Wiki Platform of Knol.
Have a Plan for 1,000,000 Page Views in the Next Year
Knol authors especially existing active knol authors need to come out with plan to have 1,000,000 page views for their knols.
What was the page view number for your best knol last year? 100,000, or 10,000 or 1000. This page view number tells you what you need to do next year to reach 1,000,000 page views.
I am happy to see 24,200 page views per week statistic on my knol portfolio. That gives me a possible one million page views in the next one year. I am sure many more knol authors will reach this milestone in months to come. Many of them are writing new interesting knols.
100-Knol Portfolios
I started compiling the list of knol authors who posted more than 100 knols. It is encouraging to see that there are may authors who posted 100 knols and more. Centurion Knollers - Knol Authors
I hope 1000 authors reach this milestone of 100 knols and each will have 100,000 page views in the next one year giving 100 million page views for the knol platform from these 1000 author group.
New Initiatives and New Features From Knol Platform
Suggestions
1. How many people use knol search after they visit a knol from a search engine? How to improve this metric?
2. How many visitors visit knol home page after they visit a knol from a search engine? How to improve this behavior?
3. Can knol convince celebrity authors to contribute articles with the same reward structure? Celebrity authors in areas like economics, politics, management, investment may attract up to 500,000 page views in a year. Persons like Warren Buffett, Paul Krugman, Steven Covey, Daniel Goleman etc. can attract visitors to the knol platform. They also act as role models and more reputed authors come online on knol.
4. Make the story of knol a b-school case study. The product manager and marketing manager of knol can make presentations in US B schools and initiate case discussion on knol's strategy and marketing programs. The suggestions that emerge out of the case discussion can be evaluated for implementation.
5. Author referral program can be implemented for promoting Knol site through a unique referral id. If anybody registers with author referral id then the referral count will be increased. Total referrals can be added to the profile and rewards can be given for authors with more referrals.
6. Advertorials can be a good advertisement vehicle for companies and knol can initiate such a service. Knol platform can be uniquely positioned for offering this advertising alternative.
7. Knol could be an outsourcing facility new online media companies. People with expertise in content generation and editing can start online media companies and knol can act as outsourcing facility for technology, storage space and content delivery. Knol can provide the domain the firm wants and can also index the articles through knol search engine. A Knol Pro service can be launched for commercial media business firms.
____________________________________________________________________________________
New Initiatives From Knol Platform (Introduced)
20.8 2009
All knol authors must be happy with the announcement. Serious scientific papers which are reviewed or moderated are being published on knol. PLOS a body of scientists for open access publishing started publishing on knol. I made a blog post on the announcement.
Reviewed/Moderated Science Paper Publishing on Knol
So knol platform management came out with a strong support statement on knol platform with an initiative. My appreciation to them.
Reviewed/Moderated Science Paper Publishing on Knol
So knol platform management came out with a strong support statement on knol platform with an initiative. My appreciation to them.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Page View Estimates of Knol - Top 800 Knols
Estimate on 13.8.2009: 10,050,481
Page view estimate for a week:
The page view estimate for a week for the top 2500 most viewed authors comes to one million. We may estimate the page views for the entire knol portfolio as 1.5 million per week. But the break even point of knol will be one million page per day. Knol authors have to put in initiatives to reach one million page views per day.
The random sample and sample data used for estimation is available in Knol Authors - Top Viewed Authors - Random Selection.
_______________________________________________________________________________________
Knol Monitor
15.10.2009
Cum Page views 683
Comments 19
20.9.2009
Cum Page views 501
7.8.2009
Cum Page Views 272
9.7.2009
Cum. Page Views: 132
Comments: 10
Narayana Rao K.V.S.S.
Half Century of Centurion Author
http://knol.google.c
Mr. Chandrak Pandya
Invite as author
Nice Effort
I added writing hundred knols campaign to the recruit one more author campaign.
EditSaveCancelDeleteDeleteBlock this userReport abusive commentHide report window
Andreas Kemper
Invite as author
Best Knol of the Month July 2009
Your Knol is the winner of the Contest Best Knol of the Month July 2009! This Knol gets the second place!
http://knol.google.c
You get 38.874 Knol Translation Points.
http://knol.google.c
Best
Andreas
What is the news regarding German Authors. Are new authors registering at good rate?
I thought you and Spiros could team up and start a knol journal for publishing research scholars' papers.
What is your take now on knol adsense earnings? Are you happy now?
EditSaveCancelDeleteDeleteBlock this userReport abusive commentHide report window
The registering rate of new German Authors is very bad. In Germany we have more internet-articles per person as in the most other countries. Also Wikipedia is very strong, this year we'll have more than 1 Million Wikipedia-articles. So Google didn't do very much to make Knol in Germany stronger.
To start a knol journal for publishing research scholars' papers is a good idea, but I haven't enough time for it now.
My adsense earnings are not growing with my pageviews. But you are happy with your earnings?
Best
Andreas
EditSaveCancelDeleteDeleteBlock this userReport abusive commentHide report window
One million wikipedia German articles. That is an awesome figure. Knol will also have such figures in German language. I am now confident of my personal knol portfolio. It gives me satisfaction in number of dimensions.
I request you to translate some of your German subject knols into English through the automatic translation and then we will see how we can improve them.
EditSaveCancelDeleteDeleteBlock this userReport abusive commentHide report window
Saurabh Nagda
Invite as author
A great SWOT for Knol
As a B-school student I do agree with you on the fact that there is a lack of platform where students can form an online knowledge sharing portal and Knol can be the best answer to that because of its features like open collaboration and rating systems.
Al'best for your targets.
Andreas Kemper
Invite as author
Best Knol of the Month July 2009
Best Knol of the Month July 2009
http://knol.google.c
If you like this Knol please vote for it.
Knol-Authors can vote if they have at least one knol which is a month old. Each Knol-Author can vote for three different Knols, but please don't vote only for your own Knols.
Best
Andreas
P V Ariel
Invite as author
Yes it is feasible
Thanks for your knols. Ariel P Verghese
Thank you for the encouraging comment. We are pioneer writers/authors on knol. If knol succeeds we all will be very happy about our early efforts to support knol. We will get a platform to share our interest and passion for a long time to come. May be some persons make reasonable amount of income also in performing a required service to the global society.
EditSaveCancelDeleteDeleteBlock this userReport abusive commentHide report window
Narayana Rao K.V.S.S.
Suggestions to Knol Management
Authors and visitors can give their ideas.
Narayana Rao K.V.S.S.
Knol SWOT Analysis
Angela
Invite as author
This is definitely a possible goal.
But anyway, I think that this is a great goal. Let's all try to strive or it!
I agree with you.
When we come across any knol, with an irrelevant subject, we can write a comment gently. When we encourage anybody to write a knol, we tell him to write a good knol. We do not want anybody just to write his name. We are not recruiting authors for simple numbers sake. We are recruiting them to contribute substantial knols (knowledge articles).
I am with you on this statement.
EditSaveCancelDeleteDeleteBlock this userReport abusive commentHide report window
EditSaveCancelDeleteDeleteBlock this userReport abusive commentHide report window
Narayana Rao K.V.S.S.
We have a different view on the way
Mr. Kalle Schwarz said
The goal is right but the way is not.
I said I like the statement. I await the different way. More the merrier before we (knol platform management and knol author team) put our effort behind a plan.